When it comes to buying a car that will last, reliability isn’t just a buzzword—it’s a dealbreaker. If you’ve been weighing your options between Mazda and Honda, you’re not alone. Both brands have stellar reputations, devoted followings, and vehicles that regularly top consumer satisfaction surveys. But when it comes down to real-world dependability, long-term value, and ownership experience, which automaker truly comes out ahead?
In this comprehensive, data-driven breakdown, we’ll explore:
- Reliability ratings from industry authorities
- Common repair issues and maintenance costs
- Long-term ownership satisfaction
- Depreciation trends
- Fuel economy comparisons
- Which brand delivers the better value for your dollar
And for those in the San Rafael area looking to make their next move, we’ll also tell you how Marin Mazda stacks up as the go-to destination.
1. Reliability Ratings: The Data Doesn’t Lie
Consumer Reports, J.D. Power, and RepairPal are the gold standards when it comes to vehicle reliability metrics. Here’s how Mazda and Honda have fared in recent years:
| Brand | Consumer Reports Reliability Rating (2024) | J.D. Power Dependability Score (2024) | RepairPal Reliability Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mazda | 85/100 | 81/100 | 4.0/5.0 |
| Honda | 82/100 | 79/100 | 4.0/5.0 |
While both automakers perform well, Mazda edges slightly ahead in most third-party reliability ratings. According to Consumer Reports, Mazda consistently earns top marks thanks to its simple engineering and fewer recalls.
2. Maintenance & Repair Costs: Who’s Cheaper to Keep?
According to YourMechanic and RepairPal, here’s the average annual maintenance cost:
| Brand | Annual Maintenance Cost (USD) |
| Mazda | $462 |
| Honda | $428 |
While Honda has a slightly lower average maintenance cost, it’s important to note that Mazda tends to require fewer major repairs over a 10-year period. The difference is marginal, but it can add up over time.
Common issues:
- Mazda: Early CX-5 models had minor brake wear complaints
- Honda: Civic and CR-V models have faced transmission-related concerns
3. Longevity & Durability: How Many Miles Can You Expect?
Owners frequently report both Mazda and Honda vehicles reaching 300,000 kms (186,000 miles) or more with proper care. However, recent engineering advances and simplified powertrains have given Mazda an edge in long-term durability without the use of CVT transmissions, which are known to require more frequent attention in some Honda models.
4. Depreciation Trends: Which Brand Holds Its Value Better?
Let’s examine how vehicles from both brands retain their value after 5 years:
| Model | 5-Year Depreciation (%) |
| Mazda CX-5 | 38% |
| Honda CR-V | 42% |
| Mazda3 | 41% |
| Honda Civic | 44% |
Source: iSeeCars
Mazda’s stronger residual value is becoming more apparent in today’s used car market. Fewer fleet sales and a more upscale brand perception are likely reasons for this trend.
5. Fuel Economy: Miles and Litres that Matter
| Model | City (L/100km) | Highway (L/100km) | City (MPG) | Highway (MPG) |
| Mazda CX-5 | 9.3 | 7.6 | 25 | 31 |
| Honda CR-V | 8.7 | 7.4 | 27 | 32 |
| Mazda3 Hatchback | 8.4 | 6.6 | 28 | 36 |
| Honda Civic | 7.8 | 6.3 | 30 | 37 |
Honda takes a narrow lead in fuel efficiency, but the gap has narrowed significantly over the years. Mazda’s use of Skyactiv-G and Skyactiv-X engine technologies has made a big difference in reducing consumption without sacrificing power.
6. Driving Experience & Interior Quality
Mazda consistently wins praise for its interior craftsmanship. In many comparison reviews, Mazda is described as offering a “near-luxury experience”—especially with the CX-30 and Mazda6 trims.
- Honda’s strength lies in its spacious design and practicality.
- Mazda’s appeal is a driver-focused cabin, upscale materials, and intuitive infotainment systems.
In test drives conducted by Car and Driver, Mazda models often outperform Honda in agility and driving dynamics.
7. Resale Market in California: The Local Advantage
In the Bay Area, Mazda vehicles are commanding strong resale prices due to:
- Low availability in local auctions
- Fewer high-mileage listings
- Demand from eco-conscious and design-savvy drivers
Looking for a reliable used Mazda near San Francisco, San Leandro, or Santa Rosa? Browse our full new inventory or explore current specials.
8. Verdict: Mazda or Honda?
Here’s the truth: you can’t go wrong with either. Honda’s long-standing reputation is well-earned. But for 2025 and beyond, Mazda is pulling ahead in key areas:
- Higher reliability scores in recent years
- Better resale value
- More premium features at competitive prices
- Less reliance on CVT technology
When it comes to long-term peace of mind, Mazda offers a package that’s hard to beat.
Final Thoughts: Let Marin Mazda Be Your Guide
If you’re ready to choose a brand that balances reliability, style, and performance, start your journey with Marin Mazda.
- Check out our latest new vehicle inventory
- Take advantage of exclusive specials and promotions
- Speak to our team directly by contacting us
Located in San Rafael, we proudly serve Mazda enthusiasts throughout San Francisco, San Leandro, Burlingame, and beyond.
Your next car should do more than get you from point A to B—it should deliver satisfaction for years to come. Choose wisely. Choose Mazda.
