When choosing between Mazda and Toyota, two of Japan’s most trusted automakers, reliability often tops the list of buyer concerns. Both brands have strong reputations for longevity and dependability—but what do the data say? Let’s break it down.
1. Industry-Leading Dependability Scores
The 2025 J.D. Power Vehicle Dependability Study measures issues reported per 100 vehicles (PP100) after three years of ownership:
- Mazda scored 161 PP100, ranking second among mass-market brands.
- Toyota came in third, with 162 PP100.
A one-point difference in PP100 is nearly negligible, but it indicates both brands deliver outstanding long-term performance.
2. Consumer Reports Rankings
While Consumer Reports identifies Toyota (and its Lexus brand) as slightly more consistent overall in reliability, Mazda remains strongly positioned:
- Toyota leads, followed closely by Lexus.
- Mazda earns consistent top-five reliability rankings.
So, while Toyota holds a slight edge, Mazda isn’t far behind by any stretch.
3. Repair Costs & Maintenance
According to RepairPal data:
- Mazda is among the most affordable brands to maintain.
- Average annual repair costs, across Mazda models, are around $462—well below the industry average.
Toyota tends to have slightly higher but still low maintenance expenses, reinforcing its reliability edge.
4. Model-to-Model Comparison
Models like the Mazda CX-5 have demonstrated reliability performance that matches or surpasses competitors like the Toyota RAV4:
- One study found the Mazda CX-5 to be “in many cases… more reliable and safer” than the RAV4.
Individual model results further support Mazda’s overall reliability.
5. Real-World and Community Feedback
Mazda owners often report surprise at how trouble-free their vehicles remain long after purchase:
“Mazda is… right ahead of Honda… top‑5 brand in the world in reliability.”
While some may cite minor quirks on newer models, Mazda consistently lands among the top reliable brands globally.
Final Takeaways
- Head-to-Head: Mazda and Toyota are nearly tied in reliability—both deliver long-term durability and low problem rates.
- Toyota’s Strengths: Slight edge in dependability scores, particularly at the model level.
- Mazda’s Advantages: Lower maintenance costs and surprising reliability on high-end or sporty models.
- Your Choice: Choose Toyota if you want the rock-solid default; choose Mazda for added style, driving enjoyment, and equally reliable ownership.
Explore Both at Marin Mazda
Ready to evaluate Mazda’s reliability for yourself? Visit Marin Mazda in San Rafael to test drive our most dependable models and learn about the confidence that comes with ownership.
Marin Mazda
807 Francisco Blvd E, San Rafael, CA 94901
Phone: (415) 454‑7000
Reliable driving starts here.
